3 Hydrogeology I: Chemical

Sunday, 18 October 2009
8:00 AM - 12:00 PM
E141/142

STRONTIUM ISOTOPE DETECTION OF PRODUCED-WATER CONTAMINATION OF WETLANDS, WILLISTON BASIN, MONTANA

Paper number: 3-11
Program: Technical Sessions
Time: 10:30 AM – 10:45 AM

Authors

Abstract

Wetlands (small lakes and sloughs) in northeastern Montana and western North Dakota are susceptible to contamination from produced water as a result of a half-century of petroleum production in the Williston Basin. The salinity of some of these lakes increases seasonally due to evaporation and some are perennially saline. These naturally saline lakes are generally a sodium sulfate type water, whereas produced waters are sodium and chloride dominated. However, distinguishing between natural salinity and salinity from contamination can be challenging using only major-ion chemistry because of overlapping compositions. Although evaporation increases salinity, it will not change the strontium isotopic composition expressed as δ87Sr, the per mil deviation of 87Sr/86Sr from the value for modern sea water. In contrast, contamination of natural water by produced water with different Sr concentrations and δ87Sr values will define predictable mixing systematics.

In an initial investigation, we sampled lakes, shallow groundwater, and produced water within a square-mile area in northeastern Montana; δ87Sr values generally decrease with increasing Sr content. The produced-water sample has the largest Sr content (168 mg/kg) and smallest δ87Sr (‑1.67‰), both of which are in the range of values (39 to 617 mg/kg of Sr; δ87Sr ‑1.30 to ‑1.79‰) reported by Quattrocchi and others in 2006 for 43 produced-water samples from the Weyburn field in Saskatchewan, about 60 miles north-northeast. One wetland sample has the largest δ87Sr value of +1.72‰ and a Sr content of 0.43 mg/kg. A mixing model with a constant δ87Sr value +1.72‰ and variable Sr concentrations from 0.5 to 5 mg/kg for the uncontaminated end member indicates that a sample of known contaminated groundwater with a Sr content of 36.9 mg/kg and a δ87Sr of ‑1.30‰ contains about 18 percent produced water. The remaining 7 samples of shallow groundwater with values between ‑0.94 and +0.21 may be slightly contaminated with less than 3 percent produced water. Results from this initial investigation show that very small amounts of produced-water contamination are detectable using mixing systematics based on Sr isotopes and Sr concentrations.